skip to main content skip to footer

Menu

Dinner Menu

Appetizers

Sicilian Rice Balls

Vegetarian
Deep fried, Parmesan and Arborio rice and tomato-basil sauce
3 pieces $6.95 | 6 pieces $9.95 | 10 pieces $13.95

Calamari Fritti

Local point Judith calamari, flash fried with semolina tempura batter, spicy pepperoncini, with your choice of garlic basil aioli or sweet chili sauce
Piccolo $8.95 |Medium $11.95 | Large $16.95

Mozzarella Caprese

$8.95

Gluten Free / Vegetarian
Homemade fior di latte, tomato caponata and aged balsamic vinegar
Ala Carte

Eggplant Crostini

$7.95

Vegetarian
Sweet and Sour eggplant caponata, shaved ricotta salata

Antipasto Don Vito

Gluten Free
Prosciutto di Parma, sopressata, marinated mozzarella, Asiago & house-made specialties
Small $12.95 | Large $18.95 | Family $29.95

Local Ricotta Crostini

$7.95

Vegetarian
Italian truffle honey, cracked black pepper

Sunday Meatball

Slow-simmered in tomato sauce, topped with pecorino romano, fresh basil and whipped local ricotta
2 pieces $7.95 | 4 pieces $14.95 | 6 pieces $19.95

Mezzaluna Fritti

Vegetarian
Deep Fried, homemade mozzarella with panko crust and tomato-basil sauce
2 pieces $7.95 | 4 pieces $14.95

Piatto Piccoli

Stuffed Peppadews

$4.00

Gluten Free / Vegetarian
weet and Spicy Peppers, Vermont Goat Cheese Filling, Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Olive al Forno

$4.00

Gluten Free / Vegetarian
Oven roasted mixed olives, lemon, rosemary & Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Small Plate Big Plate

$22.95

Cured Genoa Salami, Prosciutto Di Parma, Smoked Mozzarella, Imported Auricchio Provolone, Bread Sticks, and Tomato Caponata

Golfetta

$5.00

Salami in the style of Porsciutto Di Parma

Stuffed Olives

$4.00

Gluten Free / Vegetarian
Sicilian green olives, gorgonzola cheese filling, Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Truffle Burratta

$12.95

Vegetarian
Black summer truffle-straciatella center, Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Burratta

$10.95

Vegetarian
Fresh mozzarella pouch, creamy strachiatella center, Extra Virgin Olive Oil, prosciutto di Parma

Hot Stuffed Peppers

$4.00

Vegetarian
Hot Cherry Peppers, traditional bread crumb stuffing, Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Sun-Dried Peppers

$5.00

Gluten Free / Vegetarian

Raw Bar

Blue Point Oyster

Gluten Free
Copps Island, C.T.
3pieces $7.50 | 6 pieces $15 | 9 pieces $22.50 | 12 pieces $30

Chilled Shrimp Cocktail

Gluten Free
¼ lb $6.95 | ½ lb $12.95 | 1 lb $21.95

Raw Little Neck Clams

Gluten Free
Milford C.T.
3 pieces $3.75 | 6 pieces $7.50 | 9 pieces $11.25 | 12 pieces $15

Seafood Plateau

Small Platter

$15.95

Gluten Free
3 Blue Point Oyster, 3 Raw Clams, ¼ lb Shrimp Cocktail

Large Platter

$29.95

Gluten Free
6 Blue Point Oysters, 6 Raw Clams, ½ lb Shrimp Cocktail

From the Sea

Garlicky Steamed Clams

$14.95

2 Little Neck clams in Garlic herb broth

Firecracker Shrimp

Crispy panko crust, Sweet & Spicy Thai Chile Sauce
3 pieces $6.95 | 5 pieces $8.95

Clams Oreganata

$11.95

6 Little Neck clams with Garlic and herb crumb topping

Specialty Salads

Add-Ons
1 piece Grilled Chicken - $3.99 | 2 pieces Grilled Chicken - $8.00 | 1 piece Breaded Chicken - $3.99 | 2 pieces Breaded Chicken - $8.00 | Small Anchiovies - $3.00 | Large Anchiovies - $6.00 | 8 oz Steak - $12.99 | 3 Scallops - $12.00 | 6 Scallops - $24.00 | 6 oz Salmon - $14.99 | 3 pieces Shrimp - $4.50 | 6 pieces Shrimp - $9.00 | Lobster Tail - $10.00

Insalata Misto

Gluten Freee / Vegetarian
Romaine, sun-dried tomatoes, cucumbers, pickled red onions and carrots, and aged balsamic vinaigrette

Grilled Chicken Insalata Caprese

$22.95

Gluten Free
Grilled Marinated chicken breast, baby arugula, homemade mozzarella, asiago, tomato caponata, roasted red peppers, marinated artichoke hearts, extra virgin olive oil and drizzled balsamic-fig preserve

Insalata Con Caesar

Gluten Free
Crisp Romaine hearts, homemade Caesar dressing, toasted garlic croutons, and Asiago Cheese

Balsamic Steak Salad

$24.95

Gluten Free
Romaine, sun-dried tomatoes, cucumbers, pickled red onions and carrots, and aged balsamic vinaigrette, flame grilled steak, oven roasted portobello mushrooms, balsamic glaze

Pizza

Toppings
Meatball - $4.95 | Bacon - $5.00 | Grilled Onions - $2.00 | Prosciutto - $4.99 | Mushrooms - $2.99 | Roasted Garlic - $0.99 | Pepperoni - $1.99 | Sausage - $2.99 | Ricotta - $2.99

Margherita

$12.95

Vegetarian
Roma tomatoes, homemade mozzarella, fresh basil, Extra Virgin Olive Oil and pecorino Romano

Bronx Bomber

$15.95

Roma tomatoes, homemade mozzarella, basil, homemade fennel sausage, fresh garlic and old world pepperoni

Pizza Arrabbiata

$15.95

Crushed tomatoes, homemade mozzarella, percorino romano, hot sopressata salami, and hot chile honey

Pizza Prosciutto and Arugula

$16.95

Crushed tomatoes, homemade mozzarella, baby arugula, prosciutto di parma and balsamic-fig preserve

Dido's Pie

$15.95

Crushed tomatoes, aged mozzarella, pecorino Romano, shaved grana, oregano, fresh basil, and extra virgin olive oil

Funghi

$15.95

Vegetarian
Rosemary crust topped with smoked mozzarella, roasted portobello, Parmigiano Reggiano, scallions and imported white truffle oil

Pizza Insalata

$15.95

Vegetarian
Rosemary crust, fontina, homemade mozzarella, tomato concassé, baby arugula, shaved Sicilian pepato cheese and balsamic-fig preserve

Pizza Con Quattro Formaggi

$14.95

Vegetarian
Rosemary crust, local ricotta, homemade mozzarella, italian fontina, asiago, scallions

Pizza Montanara Don Pietro

$15.95

Slow simmered meatballs, homemade mozzarella, local ricotta, pecorino and basil on a flash fried crust, oven finished

Fresh Burgers

Our Own Custom Blend of Chuck, Brisket & Prime Rib. Grilled on a 450° Flat Top,
Served on Brioche Bun with Local Patriot Pickle, and your Choice of French Fries, Caesar or Misto Salad. $3 Extra for Truffle Parmesan Fries

Truffle Cheeseburger

$15.95

8oz custom burger, melted Italian fontina cheese, sautéed portobello mushrooms, organic arugula, and truffle aioli

Bacon Cheeseburger

$14.95

8oz custom burger, melted yellow American cheese, Nueske's bacon, grilled Pine Island onions

Lobster Burger

$24.95

8oz custom blend burger, melted fontina cheese, organic baby arugula, butter poached lobster tail, truffle aioli, twice cooked fries and local patriot pickle

Dido's Burger

$14.95

8oz custom Burger, melted yellow American cheese, lettuce, tomato, and Dido's special sauce

Brunch Burger

$15.95

 8oz custom burger, melted yellow American cheese, Nueske's bacon, sunny side up farm egg, organic arugula, and balsamic onion jam

Pasta

Sauce Substitutions
Sub Vodka Sauce - $2.00 | Sub Bolognese Sauce - $4.00 | Sub Marinara Sauce | Sub Sunday Gravy Sauce - $5.00
Pasta Substitution

Rigatoni | Linguine | Fettucine | Spaghettini | Penne | Cavatelli |Gluten Free Pasta - $3.99

Spaghettini with Meatballs

$18.95

Imported Spaghettini pasta slow simmered meatballs or sausage in tomato-basil sauce and locatelli Romano

Jumbo Four Cheese Ravioli

$16.95

 Filled with ricotta, mozzarella, pecorino and Parmigiano. Served with homemade tomato basil sauce and locatelli pecorino romano

Manicotti with Meatballs

$19.95

Handmade ricotta filled manicotti baked, with locatelli romano, and slow simmered meatballs or sausage

Fettuccine ala Bolognese

$20.95

 Fettuccine pasta, with a 4-hour sauce with local beef, pork, veal, and white wine. Finished off with imported white truffle oil and Parmigiano Reggiano

Sunday Meat "Gravy"

$24.95

Homemade sausage, veal and meatballs slow simmered in a hearty sauce served with local ricotta, locatelli romano, and rigatoni

Penne A La Vodka

$18.95

Penne Pasta in a Tomato Basil Cream Sauce with Pecorino Romano Cheese

Chicken

Chicken Cutlet ala Parmigiano

$19.95

Pan fried breaded chicken cutlets with fresh tomato-basil sauce, locatelli romano, melted mozzarella and spaghettini pasta

La Rosa Grande

$24.95

Fried chicken and shrimp duo, all vodka-tomato cream sauce, melted homemade mozzarella, spaghettini pasta and pecorino

Chicken & Shrimp Marsala

$24.95

With truffled mushroom medley, pellegrino marsala demi-glace and crisp arancini di riso

Seafood

Linguine alla Vongole

$22.95

Fresh little neck clams, linguine, garlic and extra virgin olive oil with a touch of crushed red pepperoncino

Shrimp and Scallop Scampi

$32.95

Colossal Gulf shrimp, local day boat scallops, over linguini with a traditional scampi sauce of lemon, white wine, and garlic

Lobster and Scallop Cheese Ravioli

$28.95

Maine Lobster Pieces and Pan Seared Sea Scallops Served In A Creamy Lobster Sauce Over Four Cheese Ravioli. Topped With Ricotta Salata, Green Oil and Finished with Microgreens

Scalia & Co.'s Faroe Island Creamy Dill Salmon

$28.95

Shrimp Parm Alla Moda

$22.95

Crispy breaded deep fried shrimp topped with a homemade manicotto, tomato basil sauce, with pecorino romano, and melted homemade mozzarella

Scalia & Co.'s Faroe Island Salmon

$28.95

Gluten Free
Oven Roasted Faroe island organic salmon fillet, sweet and spicy Calabrian chile-apricot glaze, with seasonal blood orange salsa fresca and seasonal vegetables

Seafood Fra Di Avolo

$32.95

Colossal gulf shrimp, local clams, Point Judith calamari with Spicy Calabrian Chile & Plum Tomato gravy over linguine

Steaks & Chops

Bistecche ala Griglia

$34.95

Gluten Free
Dry Aged certified Angus beef steak, aged 21 days, grilled over an open fire, served with garlic-herb butter and twice cooked fries

Vitello alla Parmigiano

$24.95

Crispy breaded local veal cutlet, plum basil tomato sauce, pecorino Romano, homemade mozzarella, and spaghettini pasta

Boneless Pork Chop Arrabiata

$26.95

Gluten Free
10oz Iowa Heritage Pork Chop Topped With Hot Cherry Pepper Sauce Served With Seasonal Vegetables And Garlic Mashed Potatoes

Steak Mushroom Risotto

$28.95

Sides

Truffle Fries

$6.95

Sautéed Broccoli

$7.95

Sautéed Portobello Mushrooms

$7.95

Garlic Mashed Potatoes

$5.95

Side 4 oz Tomato Sauce

$1.99

French Fries

$5.95

Grilled Asparagus

$7.95

Sautéed Green Beans

$7.95

12-inch Focaccia Bread

$3.99

Quart of Sauce

Bolognese Sauce

$15.00

Vodka Sauce

$9.95

Caesar Dressing

$15.00

Tomato Sauce

$10.00

Gravy Sauce

$18.00

Homemade Desserts

Little Italy Classic Cannoli

$4.95

Vanilla & Cinnamon with chocolate chips

Tartufo

$6.95

Vanilla & Chocolate ice cream covered in chocolate with a cherry in the center

Nutella Gelato Brioche

$7.95

Hot & toasty gelato (Ice Cream Sandwich) with Nutella & crunchy hazelnuts

Seasonal Cheesecake

$6.95

Creamy Cheesecake with Fresh Seasonal Fruit

Scalia & Co. Special Cannoli

$5.95

Chocolate chips with pistachio cream

Affogato

$7.95

Creamy Vanilla Gelato "drowned" in a shot of freshly brewed espresso

Peter's Peanut Butter Pie

$6.95

Oreo Cookie crust, homemade peanut butter fudge filling, Belgium Chocolate Ganache, mixed berry compote, fresh whipped cream

Homemade Tiramisu

$7.95

Imported Mascarpone and lady fingers

Kids Menu

Kids Pasta

$5.95

With Sauce or Extra Virgin Olive Oil. Choice of Meatball or Sausage.
Sub Gluten Free Pasta $3.99 | Sub Rigatoni

Kids Margherita Pizza 6-inch

$8.95

Kids Margherita Pizza 12-inch

$12.95

Bottles of Wine

Cabernet Sauvignon

$24.00

California 2015

Robert Mondavi Private Selection

$30.00

Cabernet Sauvignon- California 2018

Chateau Ste Michelle

$30.00

Columbia Valley Dry Riesling 2017

Merlot Simi

$24.00

California 2013

Moscato Villa Pozzi

$30.00

2018

Signature Coffees

Menu

Scalia's Signature Cappuccino

$4.95

Hot steamed milk, foamy milk, one shot of espresso.

Baileys Irish Coffee

$7.95

Baileys Irish Cream, topped with coffee and whipped cream.

Nuts & Berries

$8.95

Frangelico, Chambord, topped with coffee and whipped cream.

Espresso Corretto

$9.95

Double espresso served with Molinari Sambuca on the side.

Mocha Cappuccino

$5.95

Hot Steamed milk, foamy milk, one shot of espresso, Hershey's Chocolate Syrup.

Irish Coffee

$7.95

Jameson Irish Whiskey, topped with coffee and whipped cream.

The Godfather

$8.95

Amaretto Disaronno & Jack Daniels, topped with coffee, Chantilly cream, & crumbled amaretti cookies.

Adult Chocolate Bliss

$9.95

Godiva Milk chocolate liquor, steamed chocolate milk, Hershey's chocolate syrup, topped with Chantilly cream.

Happy Hour

Monday to Friday 3:30 to 5:30

$2 Off Mixed Drinks

$5 16 oz Beer

Stella Artois

Newburgh Mega Boss

Peroni Plae Ale

Newburgh Brown Ale

Trout Town Stout

$5 White Wine by the Glass

Franciscan Chardonnay

Nobilo Sauvignon Blanc

Estancia Pinot Grigio

Kenwood White Zinfandel

$5 Red Wine by the Glass

Kenwood Cabernet Sauvignon

Mark West Pinot Noir

Diseño Malbec

Tuscany Chianti

$5 Appetizers

Piccolo Calamari

Cicilian Riceball Trio

¢99 Blue Point Oyster

Mezza Luna Fritti

Margherita Pizzette